What the foundation is asking for
They have asked for at least five scholarships to be opened to all students, regardless of race or sex. The foundation administers the money, and the attorney general has joined the effort in court. Their argument rests on two pillars. The first is House Bill 4, the Kentucky law passed last year that bans diversity, equity and inclusion programs in public higher education. The second is the United States Supreme Court ruling from 2023 that ended affirmative action in college admissions. Together, the foundation and the attorney general argue, those changes mean the old restrictions cannot be enforced. The request does not ask judges to end the scholarships. It asks them to widen the pool of students who can receive them, even when the donor wrote a narrower rule into the gift.
A judge said no on the Newmark scholarship
Not every request has succeeded. One county judge approved removing women only restrictions from four scholarships. But Judge Eric J. Haner rejected the request to remove the requirement that the Newmark scholarship go to Black students. He did so in two rulings, and in those rulings he questioned whether the attorneys had read House Bill 4 closely. The Newmark scholarship supports Black medical school students. Lucile Newmark left the money in her 1952 will for students at the medical school, and her gift was meant for that purpose. The attorney general's office has appealed the loss, so the question is now headed to a higher court. For now, the Newmark rule stands, even as the other four scholarships have been opened more widely.
The exemption at the center of the dispute
The fight turns on one part of House Bill 4. The law includes an exemption for privately funded scholarship endowments that existed before June 27, 2025, until their balance is exhausted. Supporters of the scholarships say that exemption protects the gifts at issue, because the endowments were created long before that date. The foundation and the attorney general read the law differently, and they say the exemption does not save race based or sex based rules. Judge Haner, in his rulings on the Newmark scholarship, questioned whether the attorneys seeking the change had read the law closely enough. That detail matters, because the exemption is the clearest language in the law that speaks to old private gifts. If the exemption applies, the donors' terms could remain in place until the money runs out. If it does not, more scholarships could face the same challenge.
Community groups have pushed back in court as well. They filed a friend of the court brief saying the legal arguments for removing the restrictions do not hold up. Their filing argues that donor intent and the exemption should carry weight, and that the state is reaching too far into private gifts. The attorney general's office, for its part, says race and sex based restrictions are being removed across the state, and it presents the Louisville cases as part of that wider effort.
What happens next
In July 2025, the federal Education Department's Office for Civil Rights said it received a complaint alleging the university discriminates by administering six scholarships. That complaint adds a federal thread to a dispute that is already moving through Kentucky courts. The appeal of the Newmark loss will test how higher judges read House Bill 4 and its exemption, and it could shape how other universities in the state handle similar gifts. For students, the stakes are direct. Scholarships aimed at Black students and at women were created to open doors that had been closed, and the outcome will decide whether those doors stay open in the form the donors chose. The courts, not the donors, will have the final word for now.
SOURCES AND REFERENCES
Inside Higher Ed. Louisville Public Media.







